Choosing Between Heat Pump vs. Furnace

Posted on February 18th, 2022 by carrolladmin

Heat pumps can be an energy-efficient alternative for many households. As a result, they are quickly becoming the preferred choice over traditional options such as furnaces and air conditioning units. Unlike these, heat pumps provide both heating and cooling within a single unit.

Keep reading for a quick overview of the factors to keep in mind when deciding between a heat pump vs. furnace.

Heat Pump vs. Furnace: Heating

Heat pumps work by collecting heat from natural sources outside your home and concentrating it to bring the heat indoors. In the summer months, they do the reverse by removing heat and transferring it outdoors. Since they transfer heat rather than generate their own, heat pumps can provide a more comfortable environment inside your home.

Heat pumps run on electricity, and increasingly effective technology has led to highly efficient systems. There are a few different types of heat pumps, ranging from the standard ducted air-to-air heat pump to the more advanced ductless air-source heat pump and the solar heat pumps.

Conversely, furnaces work by creating a cycle of continuous warming in which cooler air is passed through a heat exchanger and distributed throughout the house. Furnaces run on a fuel source such as oil, propane, or natural gas. Newer options may include electrical power for a safer operation.

Heat Pump vs. Furnace: Benefits

There are a few benefits to installing a new heat pump:

  • More cost and energy-efficient
  • Help to eliminate the risk of carbon monoxide issues
  • Increase property values
  • Offer natural humidity, unlike the hot and dry air produced by a furnace
  • More versatile since they can also be used to produce cooling in the summer months

On the other hand, benefits to choosing a furnace can include the following:

  • Cheaper upfront cost
  • Slightly better longevity
  • Better operation in extremely cold climates
  • Often smoother and quieter

Heat Pump vs. Furnace: Longevity and Location

Heat pumps should last anywhere between 12 to 20 years with proper usage and maintenance. In contrast, a well-maintained furnace can last upwards of 15 to 25 years. While this is a slight difference, it is one factor to keep in mind when determining the right choice for your home.

In general, heat pumps are recommended in climates with warmer (40°F) average temperatures, while gas furnaces can be more efficient in colder areas. This means that residents who live in climate zones 4 through 7 would probably benefit more from a furnace than a heat pump.

Learn More About the Right Choice for You

At Carroll Plumbing & Heating, our certified technicians perform a variety of plumbing and HVAC services. We are well-versed when it comes to the heat pump vs. furnace debate and we stand ready to answer your questions.

One of the items to consider when comparing heat pump vs. furnace is the cost of repairs and installation. Learn more below.